Skip to main content

Chainmail (Gygax & Perren) - The Unsung Virtues

 It has been discussed to exhaustion how these medieval rules were a crucial influence in the genesis of Dungeons & Dragons. This is not the purpose of this post. I will focus on its virtues strictly from a wargaming perspective as a mass battles ruleset.


 Chainmail contains a variety of rules. I will only discuss point 1 in the following list:

  1. Medieval mass battles rules
  2. Siege rules.
  3. Man-to-man (skirmish) medieval
  4. Jousting rules
  5. Fantasy additions to mass battles rules and sieges
It is history of gaming how Dave Arneson meshed 3 with 5, added  Hit Points and created the concept of RPGs. There is plenty of books and articles discussing this. On the contrary, I will highlight 3 sub-systems of the mass battles rules that I think deserve more attention.

WEATHER


 This table in my opinion is pure genius. So simple, dynamic and elegant. It can be overlaid into any ruleset. I would only add perhaps the possibility of mist (reduced visibility) in the cloudy table. One can note some subtilties in the table. For instance, rainy spells are more fleeting than clear weather (two arrows leading out of them vis a single arrow)

FATIGUE


The BIG missing factor in many rulesets. How often do we see a flank advancing as trailblazers without pause or units charging turn after turn? The concept is great, but I admit that the implementation is clunky and hard to track. Luckily it can be simplified easily keeping the same outcomes. Moving adds 3 points of fatigue, charging 4, and meleeing 5. Each time a unit reaches 15 points it is fatigued. One turn stationary clears fatigue. Again, this can be added to any ruleset.

POST-MELEE GRANULARITY


OK, the formula seems complicated, but it is just explained poorly. The formula is better explained (and actually quite simple) in the retroclone Grognard. But the highlight for me is the rich diversity of outcomes in step 4 and how morale plays into it. This subsytem allows for the eventuality of a hundred elite bastards (5 figures in the 1:20 scale of the game) holding a flank. Metal!

In short, this ruleset strictly from a wargaming perspective (even if D&D had never been invented) is great and innovative. 

For this post I used as a reference the 2nd edition (1972)



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Simplicity in ACW

A variant for Simplicity in Practice (Battlegames issue 23) for the American Civil War FIRING RANGES   Infantry 15 cm Cavalry 10 cm (mounted or dismounted) Artillery 40 cm     RELUCTANCE TO CLOSE-IN All infantry and cavalry units that wish to charge must take a test (Elites +1). Roll a d6: 1. Unit advances half way to the target of the charge, stops and fires with 2 dice. There is no melee. 2. Unit advances half way to the target of the charge, stops and the target tests to see if they retreat 10cm (50% chance, 16.66% for elites and units in cover). There is no melee regardless of the result. 3-6 Charge normally CAVALRY DUAL ROLE Mounted: They act for all purposes as LC in SiP Dismounted: They act for all purposes as LI in SiP, except they cannot interpenetrate. Movement deduction for mounting/dismounting 5cm. Only one change of status is allowed per turn. They may fire in the turn they dismount but with 2 dice (in successive turns 4 dice). LIGHT COVER (rail fe...
Post a Comment
Read more

Best produced fantasy battlereps channels on YouTube

I will list some of my favorites in the fantasy genre and highlight a video from each one. A big caveat is that I prefer miniature agnostic and indie games, so this list must have the disclaimer *excluding Warhammer. I know there are fabulous Warhammer channels out there with high production values and millions of viewers. Good for them! This post complements my recent post about the best produced historical wargaming channels on YouTube . Skirmish Wargames . Wonderful and plentiful selection of indie games recorded with close-ups, voiceovers, fixed cams. Highlight : This Fear and Faith battlerep is hilarious and frightful at the same time. Gray Army Gaming .  High production values and interesting skirmishes. Highlight : I love his videos using the ultrasimple rules One-Hour Skirmish Wargames, such us this fictitious (for the moment) Defending Ice-Island . The Fantasy Skirmisher . Highlight : This  Sellswords & Spellslingers linked campaign is quite an eyeful and showca...
Post a Comment
Read more

Peninsular War Campaign - Turn 1 (August 1808)

This is the report of the first month of upheavals and the first decisive battle fought in the Peninsula. I'm using these rules: Campaign Rules: Domino Theory Campaign from No End in Sight (Ivan Sorensen). This campaign engine was intended for the Cold War, but it works perfectly for any conflict that has a strong ideological component like the Napoleonic Wars. It works on the basis of two tables. Each turn there are two random rolls, one in the Spread of Ideology table and another in the Spread of Order table . To these rolls a third is added depending on the outcome of that month's main battle. A very clever system by a designer notorious for rules such as Five Parsecs From Home. Tabletop rules: Simplicity in Practice by Neil Thomas (house rule: +2 for each melee factor, not +2 dice) Situation at the onset Simplified map of the Peninsula The numbers in each region represent Alignment. Positive numbers stand for Susceptibility to revolutionary ideals and the negative ones...
Post a Comment
Read more